Chainalysis Report Questions "ETH Killer" Narrative as Alternative Layer-1s Navigate Bear Market Realities

Amid the unrelenting grip of the current cryptocurrency bear market and Ethereum’s towering dominance, the long-term viability and future prosperity of alternative layer-1 (L1) blockchains remain subjects of intense debate across the digital asset ecosystem.

This complex landscape was recently brought into sharp focus by a comprehensive Chainalysis blog post titled “New layer-1 blockchains are expanding the DeFi ecosystem, but no ETH killers yet.” Ethan McMahon, an economist at Chainalysis, told Cointelegraph that the analytics firm published the report to raise industry awareness about the rapidly evolving, yet heavily contested, state of the current L1 ecosystem.

While the monumental rise of Ethereum served as the primary catalyst that allowed decentralized finance (DeFi) to flourish starting in 2020, its subsequent growing pains triggered a massive wave of innovation. A diverse array of alternative layer-1 blockchains has since been developed specifically to address the technical and economic challenges plaguing the pioneer smart contract network. For instance, as Ethereum’s historical proof-of-work (PoW) consensus mechanism and notoriously high gas fees continue to heavily impact transaction speeds, throughput, and overall scalability within its ecosystem, alternative L1s like Algorand, BNB Chain, and Avalanche have stepped forward with the explicit goal of solving these persistent bottlenecks.

“Chain comparison is important because it seems as if most crypto services are only offered on Ethereum, but this isn’t true,” McMahon explained. “There are a few different blockchains with competitive offerings that have advantages Ethereum doesn’t provide.”

To substantiate these claims, McMahon noted that Chainalysis gathered and analyzed extensive data across multiple competing blockchains to objectively determine the distinct strengths and weaknesses of each network. For example, the published research highlights the reality of soaring gas fees on Ethereum, which has driven numerous developers to build decentralized applications (DApps) on alternative networks like Algorand. Similarly, Binance Smart Chain, widely known as BNB Chain, has earned widespread recognition for its robust capability to support an influx of new tokens and DApps without forcing users to absorb the exorbitant transaction costs associated with Ethereum.

“It’s interesting to see that people are paying exuberant gas fees on Ethereum’s network. Our findings show that transactions less than $1,000 result in a significant amount of money spent on gas fees,” McMahon added, underscoring the severe friction retail users face on the network.

Despite these distinct advantages, the overarching conclusion of the Chainalysis report strikes a note of caution, pointing out that none of the alternative L1 blockchains analyzed thus far have successfully solved every single challenge associated with the Ethereum network. This technological shortfall casts a shadow of uncertainty over whether alternative L1s can successfully survive and sustain momentum over the long term.

For instance, the bitter winds of the ongoing crypto winter threaten to severely slow down venture capital and developmental investments pouring into these alternative ecosystems. Furthermore, the anticipated migration of Ethereum to proof-of-stake through the highly anticipated network merge—initially slated for later that year or potentially pushed into 2023—promises massive performance improvements within the Ethereum ecosystem that could fundamentally alter or diminish the unique value propositions currently driving alternative L1 usage.

L1 Developments to Drive Adoption

To thoroughly understand how alternative layer-1 networks plan to advance and secure their footing, industry observers must take a closer look at the recent technical developments and strategic pivots unfolding within the various ecosystems highlighted by the Chainalysis report.

For example, the research categorizes Algorand firmly among the top-10 layer-1 blockchains by market capitalization, noting a striking divergence in network activity during a turbulent period for the broader market. According to the data, during the third quarter of 2021, Algorand experienced a remarkable 65% growth in its transaction volume. This surge stood in stark contrast to Bitcoin and Ethereum, which saw their respective volumes drop by 37% and 45% over the same timeframe. Industry analysts attribute this anomaly to a growing wave of market hype surrounding Algorand; having launched relatively recently in April 2019, the blockchain managed to scale rapidly and capture a new all-time price high in September 2021.

Further breaking down the metrics, the Chainalysis findings reveal that an impressive 10% of Algorand’s total transaction volume originates from retail investors. In comparison, retail investors account for just 5% of transaction volume on Bitcoin and 8% on Ether. Analysts note that this metric serves as a strong indicator of Algorand’s operational success in facilitating a high volume of smaller, everyday retail transactions without pricing out casual users.

Staci Warden, CEO of the Algorand Foundation—the organization tasked with steering Algorand’s monetary supply economics, network governance, and ecosystem expansion—explained to Cointelegraph that the network relies on a unique Pure Proof-of-Stake (PPoS) consensus mechanism. According to Warden, this architecture was specifically engineered to solve systemic problems that require massive global scale.

“The most fundamental difference between Algorand and other L1s is the network’s ability to deliver financial inclusion to the two billion people in the world that don’t have access to modern financial systems,” Warden said.

Warden elaborated that Algorand’s PPoS consensus mechanism makes this ambitious mission possible by maintaining exceptionally low staking requirements. As outlined in the Chainalysis report, a user needs as little as a single Algorand token to participate in network staking. Emphasizing Algorand’s deep commitment to advancing decentralized finance, Warden noted that the network is fully capable of settling approximately 1,200 transactions per second, with negligible gas fees averaging just 0.001 ALGO per transaction.

“These requirements are necessary for networks to scale,” Warden stated. By comparison, the Chainalysis report notes that the current Ethereum network can only handle roughly 15 transactions per second. However, developers of Ethereum’s upcoming upgrades aim to increase this throughput considerably to roughly 150,000 transactions per second once all phases are successfully completed.

To maintain its competitive edge in a crowded marketplace, Warden shared that Algorand is actively rolling out a new architectural feature designed to slash transaction settlement times to a blistering 2.5 seconds, an improvement over the 4.5 seconds it previously took. Moreover, as the broader blockchain industry shifts toward a multi-chain future, Algorand plans to introduce advanced “state proofs.” These cryptographic tools will allow users to securely and seamlessly move tokens and data from one blockchain to another without relying on centralized bridges.

Layer-1 blockchains: How crypto winter could slow the challenge to Ethereum

“Algorand could end up being a router for all transactions across chains, since it can handle fast transactions, with little carbon footprint for sub-penny fees,” Warden explained. While state proofs and other technological upgrades are not being deployed overnight, the network has already secured major institutional partnerships. Most notably, international soccer governing body FIFA recently announced a high-profile partnership to leverage Algorand for the development of its official digital asset strategy.

“FIFA is building their own wallet on Algorand and creating an NFT marketplace that can accommodate secondary ticket sales,” Warden added.

BNB Chain also occupies a prominent position in the Chainalysis report, receiving widespread praise for its demonstrated capability to support massive numbers of new tokens and complex decentralized applications while completely sidestepping Ethereum’s crippling gas fees. Highlighting this utility, analytics platform DappRadar previously identified BNB Chain as hosting a greater concentration of layer-2 and related application projects than nearly any other competing blockchain network.

Gwendolyn Regina, investment director of BNB Chain, told Cointelegraph that the ultimate driving philosophy behind the network is to empower builders to create decentralized applications that can seamlessly scale to accommodate massive, global crypto adoption.

“This year, BNB Smart Chain will have 30 times the computing power of Ethereum and will also work on decentralized storage solutions,” Regina said. “As a result, blockchain technology will be increasingly integrated into real-world applications.”

According to Regina, the core focus areas outlined in BNB Chain’s 2022 roadmap include aggressive drives toward decentralization, faster transaction speeds, robust multi-chain integration, and heightened support for developer communities and ecological sustainability. Delving into specifics, Regina shared that the BNB Chain community recently introduced plans for enhanced network decentralization via the BEP-131 proposal. This governance update is designed to introduce a larger pool of candidate validators to the BNB Smart Chain mainnet.

“This proposal would increase the number of BNB Smart Chain Mainnet validators from 21 to 41, providing more decentralization and incentives for validators to constantly innovate their hardware and infrastructure,” she explained.

Despite such structural upgrades, the broader cryptocurrency community has continued to voice skepticism regarding the true degree of decentralization within many alternative DeFi ecosystems. These concerns were amplified following controversial governance proposals on other networks, such as Solend’s emergency voting measure regarding a massive whale wallet at risk of liquidation.

Weighing in on the foundational importance of decentralization, Raul Jordan, an Ethereum core developer and co-founder of Prysmatic Labs, told Cointelegraph that the ultimate litmus test for a truly decentralized network is whether an ordinary user can run a full node at home using affordable, consumer-grade hardware.

“This does not mean that other blockchains are impossible to run at home, but instead that there are tradeoffs,” Jordan said. “For example, BNB Chain is pretty much entirely controlled by Binance and centralized, no better than using a simple database.”

Jordan later reinforced this sentiment on social media, emphasizing that empowering individuals across developing economies to operate full validation nodes on standard computers is essential for preserving the overarching security and censorship-resistance of decentralized protocols.

Decentralization debates notwithstanding, the BNB ecosystem continues to expand its offerings. Notably, the BNB Beacon Chain—a specialized blockchain developed by Binance and its community to implement a high-speed decentralized exchange for digital assets—recently transitioned to a fully open-source model.

“BNB Beacon Chain is now accessible for developers to build on,” Regina noted. She explained that the advantages of the BNB Beacon Chain are wide-ranging, pointing to its high-speed order book architecture designed to guarantee near-instantaneous trade execution. “Harnessing native secure cross-chain support will open doors for blockchain interoperability, meaning users can seamlessly navigate the chains they use,” she remarked.

In addition to Algorand and BNB Chain, Avalanche was heavily featured in the Chainalysis research for its specialized focus on deep customizability, elite scalability, and native cross-chain interoperability. John Wu, president of Ava Labs—the primary software development firm behind the Avalanche blockchain—told Cointelegraph that the network was explicitly architected to eradicate major operational bottlenecks currently plaguing Web3 ecosystems.

“Avalanche has the fastest time to finality in the industry at about 500 milliseconds to 2 seconds,” Wu said. “This means that all cross-chain and subnet transactions are immortalized in a blink. Financial institutions building DeFi products and Web3 gaming studios developing AAA shooters and RPGs need near-instant finality. It is a precondition to success. Without it, their apps cannot work.”

Wu’s emphasis on rapid finality highlights a critical differentiator as traditional financial institutions increasingly explore participation in the decentralized finance sector. Avalanche’s sub-second finality times stand in stark contrast to Ethereum’s historical proof-of-work finality metrics, which frequently exceeded a minute, as well as upcoming proof-of-stake finality targets that some analysts estimate could take significantly longer under heavy network stress.

Layer-1 blockchains: How crypto winter could slow the challenge to Ethereum

Wu emphasized that regardless of prevailing macroeconomic headwinds or chilly market conditions, the Avalanche developer community remains intensely focused on building out foundational infrastructure. As a prime example, Wu pointed to the deployment of "subnets"—customizable networks of validators working collaboratively to achieve consensus on a distinct set of blockchains—which are opening entirely new avenues for institutional adoption. By allowing enterprises to enforce strict regulatory compliance, such as integrated Know Your Customer (KYC) checks, while completely bypassing the network congestion typically caused by unrelated third-party applications, subnets offer a compelling value proposition.

“The first Subnet engineered specifically for institutional DeFi is in production right now,” Wu revealed.

Survival of the Fittest?

Even as alternative layer-1 blockchains continue to roll out aggressive technological upgrades, the Chainalysis report cautions that Ethereum may ultimately solidify its position as the undisputed dominant player in the smart contract arena. This potential outcome is fueled by shifting market conditions and the highly anticipated completion of Ethereum’s core network upgrades. Reinforcing this perspective, Raul Jordan reiterated that upcoming improvements will soon allow everyday enthusiasts anywhere in the world to effortlessly operate an Ethereum validation node from home, showcasing the unmatched resilience of grassroots decentralization.

Alex Tapscott, author and co-founder of the Toronto-based Blockchain Research Institute, pointed out to Cointelegraph that there are two fundamental reasons to question the long-term staying power of alternative layer-1 networks.

“First, bear markets generally see a drop in interest for crypto-native applications, so if gas fees drop on their own on Ethereum, why use a newer or less proven chain when you can use Ethereum?” Tapscott questioned. “Second, the merge to proof-of-stake will improve Ethereum’s performance, so even if demand returns, it may be able to handle new growth.”

Adding to this perspective, Jordan warned that while rival layer-1 chains currently benefit from cheap transaction fees, many will inevitably run into severe network congestion and scaling walls similar to those experienced by Ethereum as their user bases expand. He emphasized that Ethereum’s strategic bet on the “layer-2 thesis” acknowledges that scaling a global blockchain exclusively through base-layer execution is mathematically unfeasible.

“Instead, many L2-blockchain solutions such as Optimism, Arbitrum and other scaling approaches such as the Polygon zk rollups are the future,” Jordan said. “They offer very low fees compared to Ethereum and high throughput.”

Conversely, Tapscott expressed optimism that any contraction in interest directed toward alternative layer-1s during the bear market will likely prove temporary.

“Long term, there will be surging demand for block space, with some developers and users willing to trade off between security for speed and convenience,” Tapscott noted. “Also, I think many alternative L1s for all their potential are still pretty early stage tech, and as they mature they will become more reliable, useful and broadly adopted.”

Tapscott further observed that historical precedent suggests layer-1 platforms originally achieved success not simply because they attracted massive pools of speculative investor capital, but because they successfully drove tangible user adoption and practical engagement. If crypto market history offers any reliable lesson, it is that brutal bear markets traditionally serve as the ideal crucible for serious engineering teams to focus purely on building resilient infrastructure.

“A bear market would be a fantastic way to assess and support projects that actually make a difference in the blockchain ecosystem as long as innovative teams keep emerging to solve real-world problems using blockchain technology,” Regina pointed out.

At the same time, harsh market downturns inevitably weed out weaker protocols that lack sustainable fundamentals. Staci Warden offered a sobering reminder that a severe crypto winter will place intense pressure on every single layer of the industry architecture.

“Crypto winter is a time when every component of the crypto ecosystem is going to be questioned and tire-kicked, and not just DApps, but all aspects of crypto infrastructure, including L1s,” Warden remarked.

Nevertheless, Warden concluded that projects possessing the structural capacity to scale efficiently and handle massive transaction volumes will ultimately accelerate past the competition, presenting a persistent and formidable challenge to Ethereum’s long-term dominance.

“Businesses or projects that are building for long-term utility and real-world adoption will accelerate and garner attention during this period,” she stated.