Malta’s financial watchdog has taken a prominent step forward in the ongoing European debate regarding blockchain-based financial services by issuing a comprehensive discussion paper that outlines a potential legal framework for decentralized finance (DeFi). Published by the Malta Financial Services Authority (MFSA), the initiative introduces groundbreaking concepts for the region, including formal legal recognition for decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs).
On June 12, the MFSA officially opened a public consultation on the integration and supervision of DeFi under the broader umbrella of the European Union’s landmark Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation. The newly released discussion paper invites critical feedback and commentary from industry stakeholders, legal experts, and market participants through July 10. Central to the proposal is the introduction of a brand-new legal category termed "software-based organizations." This classification is specifically designed to encompass DAOs and various other entities governed primarily by underlying software protocols rather than traditional corporate structures.
Rather than attempting to categorize DAOs as standalone legal concepts within traditional corporate law, the MFSA suggests identifying them under this broader software-based organization umbrella. This strategic distinction allows regulators to successfully separate the legal framework governing the organization, its participants, and its operational governance from the strict rules that govern the underlying protocol and software code itself.
This forward-thinking regulatory approach builds naturally upon Malta’s long-standing reputation as a pioneer in the digital asset and blockchain industry. Back in 2018, the island nation introduced one of the very first comprehensive and holistic crypto regulatory frameworks in the European region, attracting numerous blockchain startups and international fintech enterprises.

However, the MFSA is quick to point out a persistent regulatory gray area. While the regulator acknowledges that fully decentralized services generally fall outside the direct scope of the European Union’s MiCA regulation, it argues that a vast majority of current DeFi projects retain significant centralized features. According to the regulator, these hidden or overt centralized elements heavily complicate claims of complete decentralization, thereby raising critical questions regarding regulatory accountability, consumer protection, and legal liability.
"MiCA excludes fully decentralised models from its regulatory scope, meaning that projects without intermediaries or central control may not need to comply with MiCA," the discussion paper notes, highlighting the exact compliance dilemma that the Maltese regulator is attempting to resolve through its newly proposed software-based organization framework.
EU Regulators Increasingly Turn Attention to DeFi
Malta’s newly introduced discussion paper arrives amid a broader, intensifying push across the entire European Union to clarify exactly how decentralized finance and decentralized autonomous organizations should be treated, monitored, and regulated under the MiCA framework. As European policymakers work to finalize the implementation of MiCA across member states, the distinct nature of permissionless and automated financial protocols continues to present unique regulatory challenges.
Earlier in March, a comprehensive working paper published by the European Central Bank (ECB) shed further light on these structural concerns. The ECB study revealed that governance mechanisms and voting power control across four of the market’s major DeFi protocols remained heavily concentrated in the hands of a small number of core stakeholders or founding entities. This high degree of concentration suggested that many projects currently marketing themselves as decentralized might struggle to legally qualify as "fully decentralized" under strict regulatory definitions, meaning they could inadvertently fall under the mandatory compliance requirements of MiCA and other financial statutes.

The fierce regulatory debate continued into May, when the European Commission officially launched a targeted review of the MiCA regulation. This review sought crucial feedback from industry participants and regulatory authorities on a wide array of complex issues, including the legal treatment of stablecoin interest payments, the proper supervision of DeFi activities, and whether existing gaps within the regulatory framework warrant the introduction of additional, specialized legislation.
However, a universal consensus on the necessity of a dedicated DeFi rulebook remains elusive among European policymakers and advisors. Speaking directly to Cointelegraph at the WAIB Summit Monaco earlier this month, European Commission adviser Peter Kerstens argued that regional policymakers should prioritize the integration of tokenization into a broader, cohesive digital asset framework rather than immediately pursuing a fragmented second version of MiCA focused exclusively on decentralized finance.
As the public consultation period for Malta’s discussion paper runs through July 10, and with broader EU-wide crypto deadlines approaching, market participants and regulatory bodies continue to navigate the intricate balance between fostering technological innovation and ensuring financial stability and consumer protection across the digital asset landscape.
