Meta has been hit with a massive €805 million fine in Italy following a comprehensive regulatory investigation into a Facebook for Android feature that automatically suggests photos and videos from users’ personal phone galleries for posting.
The penalty, issued by Italy’s data protection authority known as the Garante, stems from findings that the controversial photo-suggestion feature was enabled by default. According
to the regulator, the Facebook application improperly accessed Italian users’ personal photos, videos, and associated metadata without obtaining their explicit, informed consent.

The regulatory order gives Meta a strict timeline of 60 days to switch the feature off by default. This mandate applies universally, including for individuals who have already granted the app gallery access in the past, and requires the tech giant to request consent separately if it wishes to utilize such features in the future. If the company fails to meet this 60-day deadline, the feature cannot be switched back on for any user who has not provided valid, unambiguous consent.
In response to the ruling, Meta has announced its intention to appeal the decision, maintaining that the fine is entirely "disproportionate" to the issue at hand. A company spokesperson emphasized that the feature only functions after users have granted initial permissions on their device operating systems, and noted that individuals retain the ability to alter these permissions at any time through their device settings. Furthermore, Meta argued during the proceedings that Ireland’s data protection authority should have handled the case under European Union regulatory mechanisms, but the Garante rejected this argument, noting that the ePrivacy rules invoked in this case do not provide a one-stop-shop mechanism.
The investigation that led to this historic penalty originated from a consumer complaint filed by the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection group based in Bolzano, Italy. The group initially published consumer advice alerting the public that the Facebook application was accessing unposted photos, urging users to manually switch off gallery suggestion settings within the app and carefully review the permissions granted to the Facebook application on their smartphones.
Following this consumer alert, the Garante launched its formal investigation in July 2025, which included extensive technical analysis by the authority’s experts. The regulatory body ultimately concluded that Meta had breached Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, a legislative provision that translates the European Union’s ePrivacy Directive into domestic Italian law. This specific legal framework treats an individual’s smartphone and its internal storage as a fundamental component of their private life. Consequently, any access to data stored locally on a phone requires free, specific, and informed consent, regardless of whether the accessed data is transmitted to external servers or whether tangible harm results from the access.

Investigators discovered that the Facebook application requested gallery access through a single, broad permission prompt that covered the entire application and served multiple functions with vastly different purposes. While a general notice concerning the enablement of various other features appeared first during the setup process, the authority found that it failed to make clear to users that they were simultaneously enabling intrusive gallery suggestions. Once fully granted, a permission of this nature allows the mobile application to read a phone’s entire photo archive on an ongoing basis. The authority noted that neither the individual user nor the regulatory body itself has any practical way to check which specific pieces of information are actually accessed or utilized by the platform.
The regulatory scrutiny did not evaluate whether the harvested gallery content was utilized to train artificial intelligence models, as the company has consistently denied any such use. However, the authority noted that it may separately examine a newer feature launched earlier this year that specifically allows gallery content to be processed within cloud environments.
The financial penalty equals approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue. In calculating the severity of the fine, the Italian authority carefully weighed several aggravating factors, including the exceptionally large number of people involved—affecting an estimated 20 million Android users across Italy—and the prolonged duration of the breach. The regulator pointed out that the violation remained ongoing for individuals who had not updated their mobile application, as well as for those who had previously granted broader system permissions.
Additional factors influencing the penalty calculation included a previous 2019 enforcement decision against the company and limited cooperation demonstrated throughout the course of the investigation. On the other hand, modifications that the company implemented following the initial consumer complaint were counted in Meta’s favor, although the authority ultimately judged those remedial changes to be late and restricted exclusively to users who actively updated their applications.
