Large-scale bitcoin holders are swapping the coins they guard themselves for shares of BlackRock’s iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) at a record pace, according to the firm’s head of digital assets. Amid a rising tide of physical security threats, kidnappings, and digital custody risks, institutional and high-net-worth investors are increasingly prioritizing safety over the foundational ethos of decentralized self-custody.
The current moment marks the highest volume of in-kind conversions the firm has seen at any point since the mechanism was introduced, Robbie Mitchnick, BlackRock’s head of digital assets, said in a recent interview with Barron’s. He added that demand for these asset swaps has been consistently trending upward, driven overwhelmingly by a single overarching concern from clients. Of all the reasons wealthy bitcoin owners cite for making the switch, Mitchnick noted that the single largest one is security and peace of mind.
These transactions are executed through in-kind conversions, a specialized process where a large holder delivers bitcoin to the fund via an intermediary and receives newly created IBIT shares in return. Crucially, this allows investors to migrate their wealth without first liquidating their digital assets for cash. BlackRock relies on established market intermediaries such as Galaxy Digital, Talos, and Virtu to handle the heavy lifting of these transactions, with those executing firms establishing the minimum required trade sizes.
Financial tracking by Barron’s puts the cumulative volume of these specific BlackRock swaps at approximately $3.6 billion. However, industry analysts and firm executives note that the real figure could be considerably larger, as BlackRock does not directly process every individual conversion itself. Mitchnick previously cited an even higher aggregate tally earlier in the year, telling Bloomberg in August that IBIT had facilitated more than $5 billion of such swaps, marking a steady increase from the more than $3 billion recorded in late 2025.
In that August interview, BlackRock’s digital assets chief did not shy away from naming the external threats fueling the migration. People are closely watching events unfold in the outside world, whether those involve violent kidnappings, targeted ransom demands, or broader custody failures, and these incidents are actively motivating wealthy individuals to make the switch for all or a portion of their holdings.
Addressing broader industry vulnerabilities, Mitchnick told Barron’s that recent high-profile exploits, such as the major Binance exchange hack, came as no surprise to sophisticated market participants. Most large bitcoin holders were already acutely aware of the systemic risks associated with keeping substantial funds on an exchange or inside a vulnerable hot wallet long before those headlines broke.
How BlackRock’s Swaps Became Possible
The modern landscape for institutional bitcoin products shifted fundamentally following a regulatory decision by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. On July 29, 2025, the SEC voted to permit spot bitcoin and ether exchange-traded products to create and redeem shares in kind. This regulatory pivot officially ended the cash-only creation structure that the agency had strictly required when spot crypto exchange-traded funds first launched in January 2024.
Since that regulatory green light, accessibility for large-scale holders has progressively widened. BlackRock’s minimum transaction size for in-kind creations initially started at around $30 million when the mechanism first rolled out, but competitive market dynamics and broader adoption have seen that threshold drop significantly, now hovering between $1 million and $2 million, according to Barron’s.
Tax considerations have also played a notable role in driving the institutional pitch. Converting highly appreciated bitcoin holdings into IBIT shares through an in-kind transaction generally is not classified as a taxable sale that would immediately trigger capital gains taxes, Barron’s reported. At the same time, Bloomberg has cautioned that avoiding an immediate tax bill ultimately depends on the specific financial circumstances and tax jurisdiction of the individual investor.
Beyond tax deferral, Mitchnick has frequently highlighted the benefits of estate planning. He noted that managing crypto exposure becomes much simpler when it is integrated securely within the traditional confines of a private banking relationship.
Once these digital assets are successfully transferred into the fund, the underlying coins rest safely with IBIT’s designated custodian, an affiliate of Coinbase Prime. Mitchnick has frequently described this infrastructure as an institutional-grade cold-storage model designed to withstand sophisticated physical and digital threats. As of early November, the fund held a massive reserve of 795,921 BTC, valued at approximately $60.4 billion.
Why Flow Numbers Overstate Demand
While these in-kind creations represent a massive migration of wealth onto Wall Street, financial analysts point out that they introduce a statistical nuance regarding fund flows. An in-kind creation successfully adds new IBIT shares to the market and counts directly toward the fund’s reported creation metrics, but it does not mean any new bitcoin was actually purchased on the open market.
The underlying coins already existed within the ecosystem; they simply changed their financial wrappers from private keys to institutional shares. Consequently, headline flow figures can often overstate the amount of fresh fiat cash entering the asset class during heavy conversion periods.
In contrast, actual cash flows have occasionally moved in the opposite direction. U.S. spot bitcoin exchange-traded funds experienced significant outflows, shedding about $1.28 billion during a single week in early November, marking their worst weekly performance since June. IBIT accounted for the vast majority of that withdrawal pressure, absorbing about $1.21 billion of the total outflows, according to data compiled by Farside Investors.
Self-Custody Under Pressure
The rising tide of fear surrounding self-custody is not merely speculative; it is heavily documented by law enforcement agencies and security researchers across the globe. French authorities, for instance, recorded 77 crypto-linked kidnappings, extortion cases, and violent home invasions over the course of a single year, surpassing the total figures recorded for the entirety of the previous year, according to a report by the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project citing the national organized crime prosecutor. Prior reporting from Reuters detailed a violent incident in which a hardware wallet manufacturer’s co-founder lost a finger after being targeted by kidnappers alongside his family.
Similar incidents have emerged in the United States, including a failed extortion plot in Connecticut where perpetrators attempted to force a local family to hand over their bitcoin holdings. Well-known bitcoin security researcher Jameson Lopp maintains a comprehensive public database tracking physical attacks against cryptocurrency holders dating back to 2014. Furthermore, technical vulnerabilities discovered in popular hardware wallets, such as the Coldcard bug, have periodically placed the security of single-signature hardware devices under intense scrutiny.
This accelerating shift toward traditional financial instruments cuts directly against bitcoin’s founding philosophical pitch, which champions the ability of individuals to hold and sovereignly manage their own money without relying on banks or intermediaries. Holders who choose to convert their private keys for brokerage claims are essentially trading the complex operational risk of guarding their own coins for a reliance on BlackRock, its institutional custodian, and the network of market makers operating in between.
