Why Corporate Blockchain Projects Keep Failing: Lessons From Maersk and IBM’s TradeLens

Blockchain projects continue to struggle with a staggering failure rate exceeding 90%. With every passing month, it seems another major corporate entity adds its heavily promoted, yet ultimately underperforming, blockchain initiative to a growing technology graveyard. One of the most prominent victims of this trend is A.P. Moller-Maersk, which recently announced the official termination of its widely publicized TradeLens offering—a global trade platform built on IBM’s enterprise blockchain technology.

Yet, for seasoned technology analysts and organizational theorists, these high-profile corporate failures were entirely predictable. In many cases, they could have been successfully avoided if legacy enterprises had paid closer attention to foundational lessons in innovation diffusion, organizational behavior, and technology adoption cycles.

Lesson 1: Innovation Is Not Monolithic

One of the most critical and frequent mistakes corporate leaders make is treating innovation as a single, monolithic concept. Unfortunately, business associations, corporate media outlets, and prestigious business schools often love to curate endless parades of innovation lists and awards that reinforce the misleading notion that all innovation functions in the same way.

The late Clayton Christensen made a major breakthrough in distinguishing innovation types in his New York Times best-selling book, The Innovator’s Dilemma. While Christensen’s work was instrumental in sparking a broader conversation about corporate disruption, a more granular framework for categorizing innovations comes from researchers Rebecca Henderson and Kim Clark. They identified four distinct types of innovation: incremental, modular, architectural, and radical.

While certain enterprise blockchain use cases might fit neatly into the modular or architectural categories, blockchain technology is, at its core, fundamentally disruptive. Because disruptive technologies are specifically designed to replace existing frameworks, streamline interactions, and eliminate intermediary institutions, the most successful early applications and innovations are naturally driven by smaller startups and agile firms rather than massive legacy giants like IBM, Maersk, or other Fortune 100 corporations.

Lesson 2: Complexity Is an Innovation Killer

Complexity acts as a primary catalyst for innovation failure, a dynamic that holds especially true for modular and radical innovations. Decades ago, sociologist Everett Rogers noted the inverse relationship between the complexity of an innovation and an organization’s willingness and ability to adopt it. This complexity is multifaceted; it encompasses not only the technical mechanics of the blockchain application itself, but also internal corporate decision-making processes, the massive structural changes required to adapt, and the sheer volume of new knowledge organizations must acquire just to implement the system.

Industry experts have frequently highlighted the immense difficulty of deploying enterprise-scale supply chain projects like TradeLens. Observers note that the underlying technology is inherently complex, demands significantly more computing power, and remains considerably more expensive to run than traditional, centralized databases. Compounding the technological complexity of the IBM-Maersk shipping project was the deeply intricate bureaucratic nature of the two large multinational corporations spearheading it.

During the previous wave of major technological innovation—namely, the rapid expansion of the social media ecosystem—it was not the established industry giants that built the foundational tools, technologies, and platforms that drove early adoption. Instead, it was startups. These smaller organizations benefited from short decision-making cycles, required minimal internal structural change to adapt to shifting landscapes, and were capable of assimilating new knowledge almost instantaneously.

The IBM–Maersk blockchain effort was doomed to fail from the start

Given these structural dynamics, initial successful breakthroughs for blockchain technology are far more likely to emerge through simplistic applications developed by much smaller, highly entrepreneurial firms. These smaller entities are better positioned to replace or reshape straightforward processes surrounding how daily work gets executed, products are manufactured, or transactions are facilitated between two parties.

Lesson 3: Different Innovation Types Require Different Levels of Risk Tolerance

Another vital differentiator among the four types of innovation is the distinct level of risk tolerance required for an organization or leader to act as an effective innovator. The risk-tolerance threshold for incremental innovation is remarkably low, whereas true radical innovation demands a significantly higher appetite for risk.

Crucially, this risk tolerance extends far beyond simply calculating the probability that an individual project might fail. Assessing true innovation risk requires examining the likelihood of a catastrophic failure for the entire organization—meaning that if the adoption initiative collapses, the overarching enterprise faces existential threat rather than a mere departmental setback.

A classic illustration of modular innovation is found in Billy Beane’s implementation of sabermetrics to manage the player roster of the Oakland Athletics in the early 2000s, a strategy famously detailed in Michael Lewis’s book Moneyball. This innovation carried a high degree of personal and organizational risk that virtually no other Major League Baseball franchise was willing to accept at the time.

If the strategy had failed completely, the outcome would not have been catastrophic for the franchise—the team would not have ceased to exist as a major league organization. However, the costs would have been exceptionally high. Beane likely would have lost his executive position, along with numerous coaching and analytical staff members. A dissatisfied fan base could have abandoned the stadium, causing ticket sales and apparel purchases to plummet, ultimately reducing the team’s revenues drastically.

Blockchain, as a radical form of innovation, demands an even higher level of risk tolerance and a distinct willingness to gamble on systemic transformation. Corporations that merely tinker around the edges through incremental or architectural innovations—maintaining an escape hatch where they can simply walk away if the project stumbles—are statistically far more likely to experience costly blockchain failures during these early developmental stages of the technology.

Decentralized technologies and blockchain networks hold immense promise for driving much-needed structural changes away from the modern corporate trend toward hyper-concentrated modes of production and power. The ultimate challenge facing the industry is aligning human time, creative efforts, and financial resources with established innovation principles to give this technological revolution its highest possible probability of long-term success.

Lyall Swim serves as the chief innovation officer for Atlas Network. He holds a doctorate in education with an emphasis in organizational leadership from Pepperdine University, alongside a bachelor’s degree in communications and an MBA from Brigham Young University.