Traditional banking institutions are gearing up for another legislative battle to prevent crypto platforms from paying yield on stablecoin balances. However, according to a recent policy note shared with clients and industry publications, Wall Street analysis firm TD Cowen puts the probability of Congress actually enacting such a ban over the next two years at a mere 10%.
Jaret Seiberg, TD Cowen’s Washington policy analyst, outlined the outlook in a Monday briefing, focusing on the ongoing tug-of-war over whether cryptocurrency exchanges and digital asset platforms can legally offer yield or rewards to investors who store dollar-pegged stablecoins on their platforms. While Seiberg views legislative action as fundamentally unlikely, he acknowledges that a narrow path remains for proponents of the ban, driven largely by banking sector lobbying and subtle shifts in Capitol Hill dynamics.
The core of the debate is procedural as much as it is political. Seiberg argues that it may ultimately prove easier for lawmakers to find the necessary 60 Senate votes to pass a standalone stablecoin yield ban than it would be to resurrect the broader crypto market structure bill. That comprehensive legislation famously failed a cloture vote 49-50 late last year and has already been widely characterized as effectively dead for the current congressional term following a shift in political power.
A legislative ban on stablecoin rewards would directly benefit traditional commercial banks by protecting their deposit bases. Consequently, banking trade groups are expected to renew their aggressive lobbying efforts in the upcoming Congress, operating under the calculation that recent political realignments might open a legislative window.
Why Seiberg Still Sees a Narrow Path
The theoretical path toward a stablecoin yield ban rests largely on a structural shift within the United States Senate. Key crypto advocates in the chamber have either retired or lost their reelection bids, while vocal industry skeptics are poised to assume influential leadership roles. Senator Elizabeth Warren is widely expected to chair the powerful Senate Banking Committee, while Senator Sherrod Brown, a long-standing and prominent critic of the cryptocurrency industry, managed to retain his Ohio senate seat despite drawing roughly $64 million in crypto-backed opposition spending, a dynamic Seiberg highlighted in analyses leading up to the election counts.
Despite these favorable personnel shifts for the banking lobby, a ban remains a long shot because cryptocurrency politics on Capitol Hill are notoriously complex, which explains why Seiberg’s baseline probability starts at just 10%.
Furthermore, some congressional Democrats are expected to strongly resist treating the issue of stablecoin yield outside the framework of a broader legislative package. Seiberg reiterates that there is currently no viable path forward for sweeping regulatory overhauls like the Clarity Act, arguing that Democratic lawmakers will continue to insist on strict ethics and consumer investor-protection provisions that the White House would likely reject. This ideological split makes it difficult to imagine Democrats uniting behind a narrow, yield-only piece of legislation.
Even within the Democratic caucus, lawmakers are deeply divided on the underlying substance of the issue. Senator Angela Alsobrooks, an emerging key Democratic voice on digital asset policy, has previously voiced support for paying rewards tied to the transactional use of stablecoins rather than for passively holding them. This nuanced distinction previously shaped the Tillis-Alsobrooks compromise text during earlier negotiations over broader market structure legislation.
Lawmakers also face a significant perception and messaging problem. If Congress moves to ban stablecoin yields, it would effectively be asked to prevent everyday voters from earning a financial return on their stablecoin holdings—all while traditional consumers are legally permitted to earn interest on standard bank savings accounts and money market funds. Seiberg questions whether Democratic leadership would willingly embrace a high-profile legislative vote that opponents could easily frame as stripping money away from retail investors and everyday savers.
What the GENIUS Act Already Banned, and What It Left Open
The ongoing fight over platform rewards is effectively unfinished business left over from the passage of the GENIUS Act, which was signed into law as Public Law 119-27. That statute explicitly bars permitted payment stablecoin issuers and foreign stablecoin providers from paying "any form of interest or yield" solely for holding, using, or retaining a payment stablecoin.
However, the statute does not explicitly cover third-party cryptocurrency exchanges, decentralized finance protocols, and other financial intermediaries. This regulatory gap is precisely what traditional banking institutions have labeled a loophole. The American Bankers Association and various state-level banking associations urged Congress to officially classify platform-distributed rewards as banned interest. Later, the American Bankers Association and the Independent Community Bankers of America pressed the Senate to harden the language in broader legislative proposals to definitively outlaw balance- and tenure-based rewards.
Independent community bankers have consistently warned that yield-bearing payment stablecoins could actively pull core deposits away from local community banks, thereby reducing the availability of local credit and business loans within regional economies.
Because stablecoins serve as the primary trading pair for bitcoin and other digital assets across most major cryptocurrency exchanges, the yield dispute directly impacts how bitcoin markets settle and how platforms successfully attract and retain dollar liquidity. Finalized rules issued by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency regarding the GENIUS Act left the contentious question of third-party rewards to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, frustrating banking advocates who had hoped federal regulators would unilaterally close the perceived loophole.
Meanwhile, House Democrats have begun sketching out their own distinct approach to digital asset market structure, one that envisions a substantially larger enforcement and oversight role for the Securities and Exchange Commission. Seiberg’s policy note treats a narrow yield ban as the single legislative request from the banking sector that might theoretically clear the 60-vote threshold in the Senate, even if comprehensive bills fail.
The primary reason the probability of a ban sits above zero is the proven effectiveness of community banking lobbyists. Small banks have a long-standing track record of convincing Congress to act by framing issues around the protection of local lending markets. Yet, despite their legislative influence, analysts remain dubious about an imminent breakthrough.
The ultimate test for the upcoming Congress will be whether traditional banking interests can successfully peel the stablecoin yield issue away from the broader, more contentious crypto battles, or whether internal Democratic divisions and the sensitive optics of restricting retail investor returns will keep the probability of a ban fixed at one in ten.
