In an increasingly interconnected global economy, the cyber resilience of the financial services sector is no longer an objective that can be achieved by individual institutions working in isolation. A new, comprehensive framework released by CREST, the global non-profit accreditation body for the cybersecurity industry, argues that the current paradigm—which often places the burden of defense solely on the shoulders of individual banks and financial entities—is insufficient to meet the challenges of modern digital threats.
The whitepaper, titled Cyber Resilience in Financial Services: A Whole Ecosystem Approach and published on October 29, shifts the focus from siloed internal defenses to a collaborative model. It posits that true resilience depends on the strength of the entire ecosystem, which comprises financial institutions, regulatory supervisors, and the specialist cyber service providers that support them. According to CREST, systemic weaknesses in any of these three pillars—whether through inadequate shared infrastructure, vulnerabilities in technology providers, or a lack of oversight from public authorities—can lead to a domino effect that undermines the integrity of the wider financial system.
A Three-Domain Strategy for Systemic Stability
At the heart of the CREST framework is the identification of three distinct domains, each with specific responsibilities and a unique role to play in the broader defensive architecture. By mapping these domains, CREST aims to provide a maturity pathway that allows jurisdictions to assess their current capabilities and coordinate improvements across the entire landscape.
Financial institutions, as the first domain, remain responsible for the protection of critical business services. However, the framework emphasizes that this responsibility goes beyond traditional perimeter defense; firms must be able to demonstrate, through evidence and rigorous testing, that their security controls remain effective under extreme pressure. This is a move toward a more proactive, assurance-based model of security rather than a purely compliance-driven one.
The second domain consists of financial supervisors. The framework tasks regulators with a dual mandate: setting proportionate expectations that foster security without stifling innovation, and maintaining a deep, granular understanding of systemic risk. Supervisors are urged to move away from generic requirements and toward an oversight model that considers the interconnected nature of modern finance, ensuring that individual firm security contributes to the stability of the sector as a whole.
The third domain is composed of the cyber service providers—the third-party firms that deliver essential advice, threat intelligence, penetration testing, and incident response. The framework highlights that these providers are often the "eyes and ears" of the industry. Their role is to provide specialized capabilities that individual institutions may not possess in-house. Therefore, the competence and reliability of these providers are essential components of the ecosystem’s overall resilience.
Mapping the Pathway to Maturity
To operationalize this approach, CREST has mapped these three domains through five distinct stages of cyber maturity. These pathways are designed to be synchronized; the framework warns that if one domain advances significantly faster than the others, it can lead to imbalances that weaken the entire system.
For institutions, the progression begins with the establishment of basic cyber hygiene—the fundamental security practices that prevent low-level opportunistic attacks. From there, the pathway advances toward threat-led assurance and, eventually, a state of continuous improvement where security is integrated into every aspect of the business.
Supervisors, meanwhile, begin their journey by mapping the landscape of their respective sectors and establishing foundational mandates. As they mature, their role evolves into providing adaptive, cross-sector oversight that can respond to shifting threat landscapes in real-time.
For service providers, the journey starts with the delivery of unvalidated services. As they progress, they are expected to develop deeper, specialist financial-sector capabilities that are backed by rigorous standards, ensuring that their work meets the high-stakes requirements of the financial industry.
CREST is careful to note that these pathways are illustrative rather than a new, mandatory compliance standard. Instead, the organization’s intent is to establish a common language across the three domains. By providing a shared vocabulary and a unified metric for measuring maturity, CREST hopes to facilitate faster development in areas where specific parts of the ecosystem might be lagging behind global standards.
The Need for Multi-Year Strategic Planning
A significant portion of the whitepaper addresses the timing and implementation of these improvements. CREST warns that when regulatory requirements outpace the readiness of the market, the result is often limited assurance—a "check-the-box" mentality that provides a false sense of security without actually hardening the system against sophisticated actors.
To avoid this, the framework calls for multi-year programs that allow the three domains to develop in parallel. The proposed roadmap is broken down into three distinct phases.
In years one and two, the primary focus is on foundational work. Institutions are encouraged to map their critical business services and close urgent hygiene gaps, while supervisors are expected to publish a baseline strategy that clarifies expectations for the sector.
Years three to five introduce a higher level of complexity. During this period, the framework suggests the introduction of independent assessments and risk-based testing for financial institutions. Simultaneously, supervisors should transition toward tiered requirements, while service providers move toward independent, industry-recognized accreditation.
The final phase, spanning years five to 10, is designed to reach a state of advanced resilience. This includes the implementation of threat-led penetration testing where proportionate, as well as system-wide exercises that simulate large-scale incidents. By this stage, the framework envisions a diverse, mature community of accredited specialist providers that can support the entire financial system in the face of complex, multi-vector threats.
Addressing Barriers to Entry and Regional Disparity
One of the most pragmatic elements of the CREST report is its warning regarding the premature imposition of high-level international accreditations. While such standards are vital for top-tier security, mandating them too early can create significant barriers to entry for smaller, local service providers. If a jurisdiction mandates standards for which there is no local path to accreditation, it risks shutting out qualified local firms and consolidating the market in a way that may not serve the broader interest of national or regional resilience.
To mitigate this, CREST advocates for a more inclusive approach that incorporates mentoring, partnerships, and training. Programs such as CREST’s own Cyber Accelerated Maturity Programme (CREST CAMP) are highlighted as examples of how the industry can bridge the gap, helping smaller or emerging providers achieve the necessary credentials to operate effectively within the financial ecosystem.
By focusing on a developmental pathway rather than a rigid set of exclusionary rules, the framework seeks to cultivate a robust and diverse marketplace of cybersecurity expertise. This diversity is itself a form of resilience; a market with a wide array of accredited providers is less prone to the single points of failure that can occur when an ecosystem relies on a small, homogenous group of suppliers.
Reflecting on the release of the whitepaper, CREST CEO Nick Benson emphasized the necessity of this collaborative vision. "Financial institutions, supervisors and cyber service providers each have a distinct role, and the strength of the system depends on their capability developing together," Benson stated.
As the financial services sector continues to navigate a landscape defined by rapid digitalization and evolving cyber threats, the CREST framework offers a roadmap for moving beyond the traditional, institution-centric view of security. By fostering deeper cooperation between the entities that protect the system and those that oversee it, the industry may be better positioned to build a truly resilient financial architecture capable of withstanding the challenges of the coming decade. The framework serves as a reminder that in the interconnected world of modern finance, no institution is an island, and the security of the whole is only as strong as the synergy between its parts.
